# First Mutual Holding Co. — Form D

First Mutual Holding Co. of LAKEWOOD, OH, a company, filed a Form D exempt-offering notice with the SEC on 2025-10-14. The offering totals $3.0M, of which $3.0M was reported sold. Industry: Other Banking and Financial Services.

## Offering

- Filed: 2025-10-14
- Form: D
- Accession: 0001729623-25-000003
- Industry: Other Banking and Financial Services
- Exemptions: 06b
- Total offering: $3.0M
- Amount sold: $3.0M
- Minimum investment: $3.0M
- Investors: 1
- Date of first sale: 2025-09-29
- Security types: debt
- Revenue range: Decline to Disclose
- SEC file number: 021-560699

## Issuer

- Name: First Mutual Holding Co.
- CIK: 0001729623
- Entity type: Other
- Jurisdiction: UNITED STATES
- Incorporated: 2015
- Address: 14806 DETROIT AVENUE 6th Floor, LAKEWOOD, OH, 44107
- Phone: 216 529-2714

## Officers, directors & promoters (45)

_Showing 25 of 45 people._

| Name | Role | Location |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Rafael Charles Alfonzo | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| W. Charles Geiger | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Rebecca Ruppert McMahon | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Stephen D Peterson | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Wendy L Wilson | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Amy V Davin | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Kathleen A Dockery | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Andy T Shook | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Rebecca Ruppert McMahon | Related Person | Lakewood, OH |
| W. Charles Geiger | Related Person | Lakewood, OH |
| Debra L Kaput | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Ronald W Dees | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Gary R Fix | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| William C Huffman | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Thomas J Fraser | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Thomas J Fraser | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Margaret G Wichman | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Brian J Pinkerton | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Jennifer A Raynor | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| David T Shaw | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Sue B Workman | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| W Charles Geiger | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Paul V Capka | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |
| Sara L Stehlik | Director | Lakewood, OH |
| Carl A Kessler III | Executive Officer | Lakewood, OH |

## Other filings by this issuer (3)

| Filed | Form | Offering | Sold |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| [2026-06-23](https://search.stillhousedata.com/formd/0001729623-26-000001) | D | $25.0M | $25.0M |
| [2020-10-09](https://search.stillhousedata.com/formd/0001729623-20-000001) | D | $15.0M | — |
| [2018-02-08](https://search.stillhousedata.com/formd/0001729623-18-000001) | D | $10.0M | $10.0M |

## More

- [CIK 1729623 on SEC EDGAR (source of record)](https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&CIK=1729623&type=&dateb=&owner=include&count=40)
- [This page as markdown (for LLM agents)](https://search.stillhousedata.com/formd/0001729623-25-000003.md)
- [Search all SEC filings, advisers and people on Adviser Search](https://search.stillhousedata.com/)

---

Source: public SEC filing data via Adviser Search (https://search.stillhousedata.com).
Agents: this data is also queryable via MCP tools and read-only SQL — see https://search.stillhousedata.com/llms.txt.